Best Peaty Scotch for Beginners

Smoky, strong, rich, and luxurious, getting into Scotch Whisky is nowhere near as simple as picking out a vodka, specially if you want to start tasting the smokiest whisky there is. That’s why we prepared this guide – The Best Peaty Scotch For Beginners.

If vodka is considered to be the most basic, entry-level spirit around, Scotch would be somewhere at the exact opposite end of the spectrum.

No, you need to have a better understanding of what you’re getting into when it comes to Scotch specifically – and you need to be sure you are ready for the peaty flavor bottom you’re inevitably going to bump into, too.

In the rest of this detailed guide we run through (almost) everything you need to know about not just the best peaty Scotch for beginners, but also things like:

  • How Scotch is made
  • Scotch vocab that will help you better navigate your options
  • The importance of the aging process for peaty Scotch

Table of Contents – Sip this article!

  1. Scotch Whisky 101
    1. How Scotch is Made
  2. What is the Difference Bewteen Peaty and Smoky Whisky?
    1. Peat vs Smoke – How do they get into Scotch Whisky?
    2. The Aroma and Flavor Differences
  3. The Best Peaty Scotch for Beginners
    1. Ardbeg 10 Years
    2. Bowmore Legend
    3. Bruichladdich 10 Years Heavily Peated
    4. Bunnahabhain Toiteach A Dhà
    5. Caol Ila 12 Years
    6. Tomatin Cù Bòcan

Tumbler with scotch whisky near a bonfire

Scotch Whisky 101

It can take a lifetime to barely scratch the surface of everything there is to know about Scotch Whisky, but we’ve put together a little “Scotch 101” below that should make you feel a lot more comfortable with this spirit (including how to find the best peaty scotch for beginners).

Don’t fall for the negative stereotypes of the Scotch world as being some ultra exclusive club that beginners aren’t welcome in. Nothing could be further from the truth. Most people are going to be welcoming, open, and willing to help you find something you love an effort to build and grow this incredible community.

It’s not hard to get hooked on Scotch to the point where it becomes a real passion.

How Scotch is Made

While every individual Scotch has an almost infinite amount of complexities and unique features, the incredible thing about this spirit is that it really only requires three core ingredients:

  • Water
  • Yeast
  • And cereals (we get into that more than just a moment)

Even crazier, though, is that the entire Scotch production process from start to finish can be broken down into five clear steps:

  • The malting process
  • The mashing process
  • The fermentation process
  • The distillation process
  • And the maturation process

Obviously, whole host of things have to be tinkered with, dialed in, and perfected to produce a consistently delicious Scotch that offers the peaty, smoky flavors that won’t overwhelm beginners.

But that’s not really going to fall within the scope of this breakdown.

We just want you to better understand that all Scotch is made in a very similar way and that it’s the caliber and quality of the ingredients as well as the careful touch and experience of the people producing this spirit that make all the difference. Before even entering the best peaty scotch for beginners, get to know the difference between peaty and smoky whisky!

Check out our guide on How to Drink Scotch for Beginners, here:

What is the Difference Between Peaty and Smoky Whisky?

If you think peaty whisky is the same as smoky scotch whisky, you are getting a little confused on the terminology. While both expressions mean that that whisky has smoky aromas and flavor notes, the origin of those notes are quite different, which has a direct impact on the kind of smoke you are tasting.

The difference between peaty and smoky whisky can be quite subtle, but it definitely exists. For starters, ‘smoky’ is a much broader term used to describe a dram that has a bonfire taste. Peaty, on the other hand, is a much more specific term that has to do with the early stages of the production process of a scotch whisky expression.

To find out how one differs from another and to label your best peaty scotch for beginners without mistaking the expression, we’ll begin explaining the origins of one and another.

Peat vs Smoke – How do they get into Scotch Whisky?

The way the spirit gets each flavor couldn’t be more different.

Peat is the organic matter that accumulates in bogs and it is considered to be fossil fuel. To produce some kinds of Scotch, peat is burned during the malting process to dry the barley grains. During this stage, the cereal itself absorbs the smokiness of the burned peat, then passes to the spirit itself.

While peat imparts its smoky flavor to the cereals, the general smoky flavor gets into whisky by its contact with the barrel in the aging stage of the process. Some barrels could have been used before to accommodate peated whisky or even bourbon whiskey. And, in that last one’s case, the barrels are charred before being used to age the bourbon. As the wood soaks the charred or peat flavor, it then is passed to the scotch whisky expression currently aging there.

Check out our article to know even more about Peated Single Malt Scotch Whisky!

The flavor and aroma differences between peaty and smoky whisky

As said previously, peat is the organic matter that is accumulated in a swampy soil. Because of that, the smoke that it liberates while burning will not be the smoke of a cigar, for instance. The flavor and aroma notes will be much closer to a smoke with earth tones. It can also have a grassy, seaweed or have a somewhat salty taste.

On the other hand, smoky whisky usually has dry smoky flavors and aromas, almost like a bonfire. It will smell like burned wood, carbon or even charcoal.

Glass of the best peaty scotch for beginner near a fire

The Best Peaty Scotch for Beginners

Now that you have better understanding of the ins and outs of Scotch and, specially, of peated Scotch Whisky, it’s time to dig a little deeper into the best peaty Scotch for beginners.

Let’s do this!

Ardbeg 10

Almost universally considered to be the “gateway to peaty scotches”, especially single malt scotches, this wonderful bottle is still light enough for beginners to try themselves. Also, it is one of the best peaty scotch for price!

The Sherry casting process adds a unique twist to the flavor profile that you won’t be able to find anywhere else, and you won’t be overwhelmed with smokiness from the peat thanks to the extra kick of sweetness that the aging in these barrels delivers.

Beginners can expect some fire pits smoke flavors, some red fruit flavors, and even a little bit of lemon. Black pepper, smoked meat, sweet and salty brine, little bit of vanilla, and even some nuttiness will wash over your pallet as you enjoy this Scotch, too.

The Ardbeg 10 Years Scocth Whisky was already part of our Whisky Tasting Box! Sign up for this subscription and have the oportunity to taste unique drams like this one!

If you’re only going to go with one of our recommendations for the best peaty Scotch for beginners, you probably want to make it this one.

Bottle of Ardbeg 10 Years,

Bottle of Bowmore Legend

Bowmore Legend

Made at the oldest distilleries in the Islay region (a distillery that dates all the way back to the middle 1700s), this Legend bottle from this distiller is perfect for beginners.

That’s probably going to be a little bit surprising to some, especially since this is one of the youngest peaty Scotch options made by this distiller. Usually you want a little more age in the barrel to even out the flavors and to cut down on the smokiness of a Scotch – but this one handles all that heavy lifting by using bourbon casks.

The nose kicks off with just a little bit of smoke, a little bit of sea salt, and maybe even a touch of hay. Taffy sweetness will hit you almost straight out of the gate as well, and then you’ll find yourself enjoying floral honey and vanilla flavors, too.

The finish is very brief, something that a lot of peaty Scotch drinking beginners will appreciate.

Bruichladdich 10 Port Charlotte Heavily Peated
Bottle of Bruichladdich 10 Heavily Peated

This distillery has been producing some of the very best peaty Scotch whiskey for a number of years, and this particular expression is really something special.

While considered a bit of a “midrange” Scotch option (with a price tag that reflects this), this isn’t a Scotch that people have cut corners with. A first and second fill bourbon barrel casting process followed by a French wine barrel casting finish helps even out some of the rough edges of this Scotch to make it a lot more palatable for beginners.

There’s a lot of dark chocolate, a little bit of orange, some salted caramel, and a little bit of smoke that spins around in every sip of this Scotch. The smoke is a light touch for sure – just tickling your pallet – and then it disappears as you get alternating flavor hits of white wine and strawberry jam.

This is another bottle you want to have on your shelf, especially because it is one of the best peaty scotch under $100.

Bunnahabhain Toiteach A Dhà
Bottle of Bunnahabhain Toiteach a Dhà

Another of the best peaty Scotch for beginners bottles you can on, this Scotch comes straight from Islay (home of some of the best distillers in Scotland that know how to work their magic with peat).

Not necessarily a peaty bomb, though, the spirit produced from this distillation process is matured in bourbon barrels and Sherry casks. You get some really interesting flavors – stewed plums, cinnamon sticks, and a spicy sweetness – that gets mated to a dark chocolate and almost briny smoke flavor that beginners are going to go wild for.

Caol Ila 12

This Scotch can be a little bit challenging to find, not because it’s the most expensive thing on the planet – or even the rarest – but because it’s made by a distiller in Islay that is on the smaller side of things, takes their process very seriously, and has some of the highest quality controls in the industry today.

What you’ll get with this Scotch is a subtle hint of peaty smoke, just a little bit of orange and almond, and a mouth feel that is close to olive oil with just a little bit of sea salt thrown into the mix. The salt spray that hits against the distilleries outer walls help to give it a very specific flavor profile impossible to duplicate anywhere else.

The bottle is a little more expensive than some of the other options we highlighted above, to be fair. But is not break the bank expensive – and it is certainly one of the best peaty Scotch for beginners on the market today.

Bottle of Caol Ila 12 Years on a log

Tomatin Cù Bòcan
Bottle of Tomatin Cù Bòcan

Produced in the Highlands, it’s almost unfair how smooth and how delicious this beginner level Scotch really is – especially with its (relatively) affordable price point.

The spirit itself is matured inside an always changing combination of bourbon, Sherry, and fresh oak casks and then blended together to produce the consistent flavor profile you’ll inevitably come to love.

Light, creamy, and with just a kiss of smoke (something that not a lot of legitimate Scotch options can claim), this is a beginner’s dream.

Closing Thoughts

So that’s about all there is to know about picking a fantastic peaty Scotch that has just the right amount of smoke without overwhelming newbie or beginner pallets.

Obviously, there are other wonderful options out there on the market today rather than just the ones that we highlighted a moment ago.

We put together the “Best Peaty Scotch for Beginners” hot guide to help you shortcut the research process though – pointing you in the right direction by outlining some of the best Scotch money can buy that isn’t going to smoke you out of this spirit altogether.

We would recommend you try some of the options on our list (maybe even a couple of them for a head-to-head sort of competition), but would also recommend that you try other Scotch options out there as well.

It may not be a bad idea to get a really smoky Scotch and a really light one, just to see what both extremes look like and where you fit somewhere in between.

At the end of the day, a day that closes with a glass of good scotch that you enjoy is never wasted.

Want the oportunity to taste unique peated and non-peated scotch whisky? Subscribe to our Whisky Tasting Box!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

The reCAPTCHA verification period has expired. Please reload the page.

No products in the cart.